Lovango Resort and Beach Club

What the classifiers highlight

Reachable only by boat off St. John, this family-owned resort on Lovango Cay stays unpretentious and laid-back, a wilder side of the Caribbean that's grown hard to find elsewhere. The same small company holds properties on Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard. MICHELIN awards Two Keys, ranking it among the U.S. Virgin Islands' select recognized hotels.